116 Bay Street was a decaying, timeworn property long considered a fixture of Sag Harbor’s history. Purchased after years of admiration, the home underwent a transformative preservation effort that celebrated its “good bones” while breathing new life into its architecture. Recognized with the 2011 Sag Harbor Historical Society’s Corcoran Award for Historic Preservation, the project exemplifies a community’s commitment to honoring heritage while embracing renewal.
116 Bay Street Preservation
LOCATION
Sag Harbor, New York
SQFT
4,060 SF
services
Historic Preservation, Adaptive Reuse / Reconstruction, Architectural Design, Project Management / Coordination with local review boards, Landscape and site design integration
A once-forgotten Sag Harbor residence reborn through meticulous preservation and inspired reconstruction.
Through careful reconstruction, ranging from salvaging timber and brick to reimagining facades and interiors, the project became more than just a renovation; it was a cultural restoration. Collaborating with dedicated craftspeople, review boards, and local partners, the design team achieved a balance between preservation and modern living. The home now stands as a testament to resilience, artistry, and Sag Harbor’s enduring spirit.
